Macro and Regulation

Spot ETFs Explained: What They Are and How They Work

How exchange traded funds that hold actual coins are structured, how shares are created and redeemed, and what published flows data does and does not tell you.

On this page
  1. The basic definition
  2. The parts of the structure
  3. How shares are created and redeemed
  4. Costs
  5. What flows data means
  6. Advantages and limits of the structure
  7. Why the topic features in macro and regulation discussions

The basic definition

An exchange traded fund (ETF) is an investment fund whose shares trade on a stock exchange throughout the day, like the shares of a company. A spot crypto ETF is one that holds the actual underlying coins, as opposed to holding futures contracts or other derivatives. Buying a share gives you exposure to the price of the coin without owning or storing the coin yourself.

In the United States, the first spot bitcoin ETFs were approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission in January 2024 and began trading shortly after. Spot ether funds followed later in 2024. Other countries had allowed comparable products earlier or later, under their own rules. Before the US approvals, investors could access crypto through futures-based funds, which behave differently from spot products because of costs linked to rolling contracts, a point related to the futures basis.

The parts of the structure

The sponsor creates and manages the fund and publishes its documents, including the fee.

The custodian holds the actual coins on the fund’s behalf. This is typically a specialist firm, and the security of its storage is a central feature of the product. Investors in the fund rely on the sponsor and custodian rather than holding keys themselves, so the risks are partly the counterparty risks familiar from other custody arrangements.

The exchange is where fund shares trade between investors, in the same way as other listed securities.

Authorized participants are large financial firms permitted to create or redeem blocks of shares directly with the fund. They are the link between the fund and the market.

How shares are created and redeemed

If demand for the fund pushes the share price above the value of the coins it holds, an authorized participant can deliver cash (or coins, depending on the structure) to the fund and receive new shares, then sell them on the exchange. This increases the fund’s holdings. If shares trade below the value of their underlying coins, the process can run in reverse: shares are returned to the fund, which sells coins or hands them over. This mechanism tends to keep the share price close to the net asset value, although small gaps, called premiums and discounts, can appear, especially in volatile moments or when the underlying market is closed or illiquid.

Early US spot products reportedly used cash creation and redemption, meaning the fund or its agents bought and sold coins in the market for the participant, rather than receiving coins directly. Structures can differ between products and may change with regulation.

Costs

Funds charge an annual fee, expressed as a percentage of assets, taken from the fund’s holdings. Shareholders also face the bid-ask spread on exchange-traded shares and, depending on the broker, possible commissions. A small difference between the fund’s return and the coin’s return, called tracking difference, is normal because of these costs.

What flows data means

Websites and analysts publish daily “flows” for these funds. Net flow is usually derived from changes in shares outstanding or assets, converted to a currency value. A positive figure means more shares were created than redeemed that day, and a negative figure means the opposite.

It is tempting to treat flows as a direct measure of buying pressure, but caution is needed.

  • They are not all new demand. Some flows may reflect investors switching between funds or from other products.
  • They can be hedging or arbitrage. Firms that use the funds in trading strategies, such as holding the fund while shorting futures, may create flows with no directional view.
  • Timing issues. Daily figures are reported after the market close and can be revised or defined differently across data providers.
  • Correlation is not causation. Inflows commonly occur when prices are rising, which may mean flows follow price rather than drive it.
  • Scale. A large flow in absolute terms still needs to be compared with total market trading volume to judge its importance.

Therefore flows are best read as one sentiment and access indicator among others, not a forecast.

Advantages and limits of the structure

For some investors the appeal is convenience: a familiar brokerage account, regulated product, no need to manage keys, and sometimes tax-advantaged account eligibility. The trade-offs include fees, a limited trading schedule compared with the around-the-clock coin market, and no ability to use the underlying coins for payments or decentralised applications. Holders also depend on the sponsor and custodian doing their jobs properly.

Why the topic features in macro and regulation discussions

Spot ETFs are a result of regulatory decisions, and the way markets reacted around their approval is discussed in the context of regulatory news. They also broaden access for traditional investors, which is one of the channels linking the wider financial system to crypto.

Cryptocurrency prices are volatile, and the value of fund shares can fall as well as rise, including to zero in the worst case. This article is educational and is not financial, tax or legal advice.

The complete guide to macro and regulation

How Macroeconomic Conditions Affect Crypto Markets
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →